Best Toddy Coffee Makers (KEY FACTORS)

By Jamie — Coffee Equipment Reviewer | Last Updated on January 21, 2026

Note: This page contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases when you click on the link, but you are not charged extra.

Coffee culture has evolved significantly over the years, and one of the more unique and highly valued brewing methods in the world of specialty coffee is cold brew. The Toddy Coffee Maker, in particular, has become an icon for producing this smooth, rich, and highly caffeinated beverage. Developed in the 1960s, the Toddy Coffee Maker is designed specifically to create cold brew coffee by slowly extracting the flavors from coffee grounds in cold water over an extended period. It allows coffee lovers to experience coffee in a whole new way, offering a less acidic, more concentrated brew than traditional hot brewing methods. But what sets the Toddy Coffee Maker apart from other brewing devices? This guide will explore the reasons why it’s worth considering, how to choose the best one for your needs, and how to use and care for your Toddy Coffee Maker for optimal results.

Best Toddy Coffee Makers: Comparison Table

	Features	Pros	Cons
Toddy Cold Brew SystemCheck Price	Cold brew coffee concentrate Reusable filter 2.5-quart capacity Easy to clean Brews coffee or tea	Makes smooth, low-acid coffee Ideal for large batches Durable design Reusable filters are eco-friendly	Takes a long time to brew (12-24 hours) Can be bulky for smaller kitchens
OXO Good Grips Cold Brew Coffee MakerCheck Price	Brew up to 32 ounces of cold brew Brew cycle of 12-24 hours Stainless steel filter Dishwasher safe parts Pour spout for easy serving	Compact and sleek design Brews coffee in under 24 hours Stainless steel filter is easy to clean No need for paper filters	Smaller capacity compared to other models Can be a bit tricky to set up initially
KitchenAid Cold Brew Coffee MakerCheck Price	Brew up to 28 ounces Stainless steel mesh filter Brew coffee in 12 to 24 hours Integrated tap for easy dispensing Brews both cold brew coffee and iced tea	Sleek design with integrated tap for easy pouring Brews quickly and efficiently Versatile – works for both coffee and tea Takes up less counter space	Price is on the higher side Smaller batch capacity
Hario Mizudashi Cold Brew Coffee PotCheck Price	Brews up to 1 liter Glass body with a bamboo lid Brew cycle of 12-24 hours Simple design Brew coffee concentrate	Elegant and minimalist design Affordable and easy to use Glass material preserves flavor well Great for single servings or small batches	Smaller capacity Glass is fragile, so be careful
Cuisinart Cold Brew Coffee MakerCheck Price	Makes up to 7 cups of cold brew Brew cycle of 12-24 hours Removable steeping basket Reversible filter for different brew strengths Easy-pour spout	Compact size, great for smaller kitchens Customizable brew strength Simple to use and clean Affordable compared to other brands	Not ideal for larger batches Can be a little messy when pouring

Best Toddy Coffee Makers

Toddy Cold Brew System

Check Price

The Toddy Cold Brew System is the gold standard when it comes to cold brew coffee makers. If you’re serious about your coffee and enjoy a smooth, strong brew, this is a fantastic pick. It’s built to make larger batches of coffee concentrate, so if you drink a lot of cold brew, you’re in the right place. While it takes time to brew (12 to 24 hours), the result is worth it – the concentrate can be stored in your fridge and diluted as needed. Plus, cleaning is a breeze, and it’s a reusable system, which makes it an eco-friendly choice!

Features:

• Cold brew coffee concentrate
• Reusable filter
• 2.5-quart capacity
• Easy to clean
• Brews coffee or tea

Pros:

• Makes smooth, low-acid coffee
• Ideal for large batches
• Durable design
• Reusable filters are eco-friendly

Cons:

• Takes a long time to brew (12-24 hours)
• Can be bulky for smaller kitchens

OXO Good Grips Cold Brew Coffee Maker

Check Price

The OXO Good Grips Cold Brew Coffee Maker is perfect for those who want to make a solid cup of cold brew without a lot of fuss. The 32-ounce capacity isn’t huge, but it’s perfect for individuals or couples who don’t need to make a full pitcher every day. What makes it stand out is its simple yet effective design – the stainless steel filter is reusable and easy to clean, and it brews a concentrated coffee that’s low in acidity. You’ll love how easy it is to use, but expect a little bit of trial and error the first time you set it up.

Features:

• Brew up to 32 ounces of cold brew
• Brew cycle of 12-24 hours
• Stainless steel filter
• Dishwasher safe parts
• Pour spout for easy serving

Pros:

• Compact and sleek design
• Brews coffee in under 24 hours
• Stainless steel filter is easy to clean
• No need for paper filters

Cons:

• Smaller capacity compared to other models
• Can be a bit tricky to set up initially

KitchenAid Cold Brew Coffee Maker

Check Price

The KitchenAid Cold Brew Coffee Maker takes your cold brew game to the next level. This one has a super convenient integrated tap that lets you pour your concentrate directly from the carafe without making a mess. It’s stylish and compact, so it won’t take up much space in your kitchen. Plus, you can make iced tea with it too, which adds a lot of versatility for those hot summer days. Although it’s a bit pricier and has a smaller batch size, it’s perfect for those who want convenience and style without sacrificing flavor.

Features:

• Brew up to 28 ounces
• Stainless steel mesh filter
• Brew coffee in 12 to 24 hours
• Integrated tap for easy dispensing
• Brews both cold brew coffee and iced tea

Pros:

• Sleek design with integrated tap for easy pouring
• Brews quickly and efficiently
• Versatile – works for both coffee and tea
• Takes up less counter space

Cons:

• Price is on the higher side
• Smaller batch capacity

Hario Mizudashi Cold Brew Coffee Pot

Check Price

The Hario Mizudashi Cold Brew Coffee Pot is a beautiful, minimalist option for those who appreciate simplicity. Made from glass with a charming bamboo lid, this coffee maker is both functional and aesthetically pleasing. It’s great for small batches (1 liter), and the brewing process is straightforward – no fuss, just good coffee. While it’s incredibly easy to use, the glass material can be fragile, so you’ll need to be gentle with it. If you’re just making a cup or two and want something that looks as good as it works, this is a fantastic choice!

Features:

• Brews up to 1 liter
• Glass body with a bamboo lid
• Brew cycle of 12-24 hours
• Simple design
• Brew coffee concentrate

Pros:

• Elegant and minimalist design
• Affordable and easy to use
• Glass material preserves flavor well
• Great for single servings or small batches

Cons:

• Smaller capacity
• Glass is fragile, so be careful

Cuisinart Cold Brew Coffee Maker

For a smaller, more budget-friendly option, the Cuisinart Cold Brew Coffee Maker is a solid choice. It’s perfect if you’re just starting with cold brew or don’t need to brew huge batches. The removable steeping basket makes cleanup a breeze, and you can adjust the strength of your brew with a reversible filter. While it might get a bit messy when pouring, the easy-pour spout helps to reduce spills. If you’re looking for simplicity, affordability, and a smaller footprint, this one’s a great pick.

Check Price

Features:

• Makes up to 7 cups of cold brew
• Brew cycle of 12-24 hours
• Removable steeping basket
• Reversible filter for different brew strengths
• Easy-pour spout

Pros:

• Compact size, great for smaller kitchens
• Customizable brew strength
• Simple to use and clean
• Affordable compared to other brands

Cons:

• Not ideal for larger batches
• Can be a little messy when pouring

Reasons To Choose Toddy Coffee Makers

When it comes to brewing cold brew coffee at home, the Toddy Coffee Maker stands out as a preferred choice for many coffee enthusiasts. Here’s why:

Superior Cold Brew Quality

The Toddy Coffee Maker is built to provide a smooth, well-balanced cold brew with minimal acidity. Its brewing method, which involves steeping coffee grounds in cold water for 12 to 24 hours, extracts coffee’s flavors gently, preserving the oils and compounds that give it depth without the bitterness or acidity associated with hot brewing. This makes Toddy cold brew coffee less harsh on the stomach, especially for those sensitive to acidity.

Large Batch Brewing

Unlike many other cold brew methods that make small amounts of coffee, the Toddy Coffee Maker allows you to brew larger quantities-up to 1.5 liters (about 50 ounces) of coffee at a time. This is ideal for households that consume coffee daily or for anyone who prefers to prepare large batches of cold brew in advance. The concentrated cold brew also lasts up to two weeks in the fridge, making it perfect for meal prepping or serving guests.

Ease Of Use

The Toddy Coffee Maker is user-friendly, with a straightforward design that doesn’t require any complicated machinery. It consists of a brewing container, a filter, and a drip mechanism. This simplicity means that even novice coffee brewers can produce café-quality cold brew with minimal effort. No fancy gadgets or advanced knowledge of brewing is required.

Less Mess

Toddy coffee makers feature a unique filtration system that minimizes the mess often associated with cold brew brewing. The Toddy’s felt filters trap coffee grounds effectively, so you don’t have to worry about grounds slipping through into your cold brew concentrate. This system keeps the process cleaner compared to many DIY cold brew methods, which may require cheesecloth or paper filters that can be cumbersome.

Versatility

The Toddy Coffee Maker isn’t limited to just coffee; it can also be used to brew tea. Many Toddy users enjoy experimenting with different teas for cold infusion. With its versatility, the Toddy is an excellent addition to any kitchen, whether you’re a coffee purist or someone who enjoys experimenting with flavors.

Buyer Guide For Toddy Coffee Makers

Choosing the right Toddy Coffee Maker for your needs requires considering a few key factors. Here’s what to look out for:

Size Of The Brewer

The most common Toddy Coffee Maker sizes are 1-quart, 1.5-quart, and 2-quart. The size you choose depends on your consumption habits. If you only need one or two cups a day, the 1-quart size will suffice. However, for larger families or if you like to have cold brew ready for a week, the larger models are a better fit.

Quality Of Filters

The filters are a critical component of the brewing process. Toddy uses felt filters, which are highly effective at trapping coffee grounds while still allowing water to flow through during the steeping process. However, not all felt filters are created equal, and the quality of the filter can impact the brew’s taste and the ease of cleaning. Opt for a model that includes durable, high-quality filters or ensures that replacement filters are easy to obtain.

Material And Durability

Most Toddy Coffee Makers are made from plastic, though higher-end models may incorporate glass or stainless steel components for added durability. If you plan to use your Toddy Coffee Maker frequently, consider investing in a model that is well-built and resistant to wear and tear. It’s worth noting that while plastic is lightweight and affordable, it can degrade over time, especially when exposed to hot water or sunlight.

Ease Of Cleaning

Cold brew coffee requires a slow extraction process, which can sometimes lead to a buildup of coffee oils and grounds in your brewing equipment. Some Toddy models are easier to clean than others. Look for features like wide openings and removable parts to make the cleaning process simpler.

Price

Toddy Coffee Makers are relatively affordable compared to other high-end brewing systems like espresso machines or pour-over kits. However, prices can vary depending on the model, with premium versions costing more due to enhanced materials or added features. If you’re new to cold brew or want to experiment, consider starting with a budget-friendly version.

Key Features To Consider

To make the most of your cold brew experience, here are some key features to keep in mind when selecting a Toddy Coffee Maker:

Brewing Capacity

The capacity of your Toddy Coffee Maker will determine how much cold brew you can make at once. As mentioned earlier, typical capacities range from 1 quart to 2 quarts. If you frequently entertain guests or prefer a week’s worth of coffee at your fingertips, larger models are a smart choice.

Filter System

The quality of the filter system plays a crucial role in the extraction process. Toddy uses reusable felt filters that provide a cleaner, smoother cold brew experience. These filters can be washed and reused multiple times, making them environmentally friendly and cost-effective in the long run.

Brewing Time

Though the brewing time for cold brew is longer than other brewing methods, it’s important to consider how quickly the Toddy Coffee Maker produces a batch. Most models brew within 12-24 hours, but factors like room temperature, grind size, and water ratio can influence the time needed for extraction.

Drip Mechanism

Toddy Coffee Makers come with a specialized lid that allows for easy drainage of brewed coffee. This drip mechanism ensures a smooth, controlled flow of the coffee concentrate into the storage container below, preventing overflow or spillage.

Filter Replacement Availability

Over time, the filters may wear out and need replacing. It’s important to check that the brand offers replacement filters and that they are easy to purchase. The availability and cost of replacement filters can influence your long-term satisfaction with the product.

Best Practices

To get the best results from your Toddy Coffee Maker, follow these tips for a smooth, flavorful cold brew:

Use Fresh, Coarsely Ground Coffee

For optimal extraction, use freshly ground, coarser coffee grounds. The grind size is crucial because finer grounds can clog the filters and make it difficult for the water to flow through properly. Aim for a coarser grind to mimic the texture of sea salt.

Experiment With Coffee-to-Water Ratios

The ideal coffee-to-water ratio can vary depending on your taste preferences. A common recommendation is 1:4 or 1:5, but you can adjust the ratio depending on how strong you want your cold brew concentrate. A higher ratio of coffee will yield a more intense brew, while a lower ratio will produce a lighter, more diluted taste.

Brew For 12-24 Hours

Let your coffee steep for at least 12 hours, but don’t exceed 24 hours, as over-brewing can lead to overly strong, bitter coffee. The brewing time also depends on the ambient temperature and your personal flavor preference.

Store Coffee Properly

Once brewed, store your cold brew concentrate in an airtight container in the fridge to preserve its flavor and freshness. Cold brew coffee can typically last up to two weeks in the refrigerator, though it’s best to consume it within the first few days for peak freshness.

Maintenance And Cleaning Guidelines

To ensure your Toddy Coffee Maker lasts a long time and consistently brews great coffee, regular cleaning is essential:

Clean After Every Brew

After each batch, clean your Toddy immediately to prevent coffee oils from building up. Disassemble the brewing container, filter, and drip mechanism, and rinse them with warm water. Use mild dish soap if necessary but avoid harsh chemicals that could damage the components.

Dry The Components Thoroughly

After cleaning, allow all components to dry completely before reassembling. Moisture left behind can cause mold or mildew to grow in your brewing equipment.

Replace Filters Periodically

Over time, the felt filters may become clogged or lose their effectiveness. Toddy recommends replacing the filters every 3-6 months, depending on how frequently you use the maker. Keep an eye on the filters for any signs of wear, such as tears or excessive buildup, and replace them as needed.

Best Places To Buy Toddy Coffee Makers

There are several places to buy a Toddy Coffee Maker, each offering different pricing, delivery options, and customer service experiences. The best options include:

1. Official Toddy Website – The most reliable source for authentic Toddy products, including accessories and replacement filters.
2. Amazon – Convenient for fast shipping, often with reviews from other customers to help you make an informed decision.
3. Specialty Coffee Shops – Some high-end coffee retailers may carry Toddy Coffee Makers, allowing you to see the product in person before purchasing.
4. Retailers like Bed Bath & Beyond – These stores offer a wide selection of coffee equipment and often have sales or discounts.
5. Walmart – A budget-friendly option, Walmart often carries Toddy products both online and in select stores.

Wrapping Up

The Toddy Coffee Maker is a top-tier choice for anyone serious about crafting the perfect cold brew at home. Its simplicity, efficiency, and ability to create smooth, full-bodied cold brew concentrate have earned it a loyal following among coffee lovers. Whether you’re new to cold brew or an experienced enthusiast, understanding the best features, practices, and places to buy can help you get the most out of your Toddy Coffee Maker.